EDITORIAL
The Shame of American Health Care
By THE EDITORIAL BOARD
Published: November 17, 2013 918 Comments
Even as Americans struggle with the changes required by health care reform, an international survey released last week by the Commonwealth Fund , a research organization, shows why change is so necessary.
Today's Editorials
Editorial: Thailand’s Latest Troubles (November 18, 2013)
Editorial: For Assaulted Veterans, a Second Battle(November 18, 2013)
Editorial: Lincoln at Gettysburg Long Ago(November 18, 2013)
Connect With Us on Twitter
For Op-Ed, follow@nytopinion and to hear from the editorial page editor, Andrew Rosenthal , follow @andyrNYT.
Readers’ Comments
"When will the government come to its senses and embrace a single payer system? I would think all American businesses would be ecstatic to get out from under the burden... ."Stan D., British Columbia
The report found that by virtually all measures of cost, access to care and ease of dealing with insurance problems, Americans fared poorly compared with people in other advanced countries. The survey covered 20,000 adults in the United States and 10 other industrial nations — Australia, Canada, France , Germany, theNetherlands , New Zealand, Norway, Sweden , Switzerland and Britain, all of which put in place universal or near-universal health coverage decades ago. The United States spends far more than any of these countries on a per capita basis and as a percent of the national economy.
For that, it gets meager results. Some 37 percent of American adults went without recommended care, did not see a doctor when sick or failed to fill prescriptions in the past year because of costs, compared with 4 percent in Britain and 6 percent in Sweden. Nearly a quarter of American adults could not pay medical bills or had serious problems paying them compared with less than 13 percent in France and 7 percent or less in five other countries. Even Americans who were insured for the entire year were more likely than adults abroad to forgo care because of costs, an indication of how skimpy some insurance policies are.
When Americans got sick, they had to wait longer than people in most of the other countries to get help. Fewer than half were able to get same-day or next-day appointments with a doctor or nurse; one in four had to wait six days or longer. (Only Canada fared worse on both counts.) But Americans got quicker access to specialists than adults in all but two other countries.
The complexity of the American insurance system is also an issue. Some 32 percent of consumers spent a lot of time on insurance paperwork or in disputes with their insurer over denials of payment for services they thought were covered.
The Affordable Care Act was created to address these problems by covering tens of millions of uninsured people and providing subsidies to help many of them pay for policies; by setting limits on the out-of-pocket costs that patients must bear; and by requiring that all policies cover specified benefits.
Americans are understandably frustrated with the Obama administration’s failure to produce a functioning website. President Obama ’s erroneous statements that all people who like their current insurance policies can keep them — not true for many people buying insurance in the individual market — has added to anger and misunderstanding. The reform law, however imperfect, is needed to bring the dysfunctional American health care system up to levels already achieved in other advanced nations.
Get Free E-mail Alerts on These Topics
Log in to see what your friends are sharing on nytimes.com.Privacy Policy | What’s This?
What’s Popular Now 
Log in to discover more articles
based on what you‘ve read.
based on what you‘ve read.
INSIDE NYTIMES.COM
OPINION »Disunion: Lincoln’s Gettysburg Sound Bite
Rarely was so much compressed into such simple elements.
| OPINION »When Doctors Disagree
Room for Debate asks, what should patients do when the latest medical recommendations divide the medical community?
|
918 Comments